Fear is a great motivator.
Is it?
According to Merriam-Webster fear is defined as follows: “an unpleasant often strong emotion caused by anticipation or awareness of danger : an instance of this emotion: a state marked by this emotion: anxious concern : solicitude: profound reverence and awe especially toward God: reason for alarm : danger.”
While researching the definition of fear, I found that fear not only has a psychological definition, which is not at all surprising, but it also has a medical definition and is accepted as a diagnosis according to the North American Nursing Diagnosis Association.
The Psychology Today website points out what most of us know, without fear, we would not be able to prepare and to defend ourselves from legitimate danger and threats. Fear may also prevent us from doing things that are unwise, even if that fear is strictly fear of consequences.
The online source Elite Daily, with which I am not very familiar, posted an article suggesting we embrace fear as a motivator. The article by Ashley Arcel entitled “5 Reasons Why You Should Use Fear as Motivation to Achieve Greater Things,” suggests that “Fear means something important is about to happen.” The author also suggests that “embracing fear means embracing growth,” and that fear should become a friend of ours because it is part of life.
While fear is certainly part of life, and while the “conquering” of our fears may lead to personal growth, it’s not always the case that fear is an indicator of positive action. It is likely not always associated with something legitimately important either.
If we look back at the Merriam-Webster definition, we see that fear can show itself as the anticipation of danger. Many times, especially for those of us who are prone to excessive anxiety or worry, fear is just a shadow. It passes away without anything significant having occurred.
Psychology Today released an article in 2009 entitled “The Most Powerful Motivator: How Fear Is Etched Into Our Brains.” Author Robert Evans Williams Jr argues that fear is a negative motivator. He points to the paralyzing affects of fear as his primary reasoning in this article, and cites another of his own articles entitled “Fear vs. Power” regarding the negative impact of using fear as a motivational tool.
Out of curiosity, I quickly read through “Fear vs. Power.” The 2013 article focused primarily on the strained relationship between police in many communities and the people that the police departments are there to serve and protect. He does though, in a way, make the point I was driving toward in this post.
He concludes his article with the following sentence:
“In her book, Freedom from Fear, Nobel Peace Prize winner and Burmese opposition leader, Aung San Suu Kyi said, ‘It is not power that corrupts but fear. Fear of losing power corrupts those who wield it and fear of the scourge of power corrupts those who are subject to it.'”
I believe fear has recently taken hold in our country. It’s not just my opinion, but, given the title of my blog, I have been listening, reading, and observing since mid 2016.
I have read posts and listened to discussions prior to the election in which many on the one side feared losing their right to own weapons and feared losing their right to certain aspects of their religious freedoms while many on the other side feared losing their right to be treated equally or feared losing the opportunity to continue to live in the United States.
Those considering a third option feared that the candidate might not know enough about geography to be a world leader, or that his ideas regarding limiting government were unrealistic. Even more people feared casting a vote for a third party because they were told that their vote would be wasted or would lead to a terrible outcome by robbing someone else of votes.
Now that the election has taken place, the votes have been counted, and the inauguration has taken place, the fear continues to escalate it seems.
On the day of the inauguration, a few chose to express their displeasure through destructive and violent behavior. As I read commentary on the rioting, I saw many people defending the actions of those who participated, not in the peaceful marches, but in the riots. The comments carried a universal theme throughout, “they’re afraid that….”
In some cases “fear of the scourge of power” has been sadly well earned. But in some cases fear of the unknown can cloud judgement and can stand in the way of our accomplishing great things rather than propel us to accomplish great things.
While fear is certainly part of each of our lives, and while it must be met head on at times, I do not believe fear is the best of motivators. Fear is often the basis for prejudice, rash judgements, emotional rather than rational decision making, and unproductive action taking.
There are problems in our world, our country, our communities, and in our own lives.
As we consider the problems in our country and in our communities in particular, we can avoid the unproductive aspects of fear by sifting through the hyperbole, looking beyond the sensationalism – particularly in the headlines, and challenging the biases (that we all have) and getting as close to the actual facts as possible; then focusing on those issues that are truly significant rather than viewing every shadow someone casts as a catastrophic threat; and finally formulating a plan to become appropriately involved when we believe action is needed.
While it is inaccurate to say that fear is not a motivator, fear is an emotion, often fueled through a symbiotic relationship with other emotions. Keeping fear in perspective should allow us to think things through and to find motivation through the more viable facets of our lives.
Many of us are aware of that inspirational line from the inaugural address of a former President who was, according to historical records, not well known by the nation he was about to lead, yet Franklin D. Roosevelt delivered the now frequently quoted sentence with confidence: “First of all, let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself. ”
As I listened to his inaugural address, I found that another of his powerful statements allows for hope to replace fear: “This great nation will endure, as it has endured….”